His stats shock you – two consecutive one-hitters, zero earned runs in 42-plus innings, 11-1 record, and a 1980s hairstyle to boot.
Mets knuckleballer R.A. Dickey has developed into one of the National League’s premier pitchers. If he continues at this pace, an All Star Game start, and maybe even the Cy Young Award, could be on Dickey’s horizon.
This is probably as good a time as any to dig your R.A. Dickey cards out of hiding, to watch the value multiply.
Only problem? Despite his 15-year card career, Dickey has slid through the hobby cracks, with scant offerings available from his pre-Mets days.
Dickey only has 250 certified autograph cards on the market. No, that’s not the number of different autograph issues – that’s the total number of cards he’s signed, all featured in 2004 Upper Deck USA Baseball (Dickey earned a bronze metal in the 1996 Olympics).
Memorabilia cards? None.
His rookie, 1997 Bowman, can be yours for vending machine snack prices.
Dickey is finally the dominant pitcher the Rangers hoped he would become when they drafted him in the first round of the 1996 draft (other draftees that year include Kris Benson, Travis Lee, Eric Chavez and Jake Westbrook).
The world was bright for Robert Allen Dickey then. The hurler had just graduated from the University of Tennessee, ready to take on the professional baseball world.
But Dickey’s financial future and cardboard career were undercut when the Rangers gave him a post-draft physical and noticed he was missing an elbow ligament. Forget throwing a fastball, he shouldn’t have been able to turn a doorknob without pain, doctors told him.
The Rangers, concerned by the prognosis, reduced Dickey’s signing bonus from $810,000 to $75,000, and the can’t-miss prospect – as well as cardboard – attention disappeared. Since Dickey wasn’t a blue-chipper anymore, the card companies devoted checklist space to other Rangers prospects at the time, players such as Mike Lamb, Carlos Pena, Danny Kolb and Corey Lee. (Lee, with one Major League appearance to his credit and a career ERA of 27.00, boasts nine different autograph releases, including 1998 Bowman and 2001 Fleer Autographics.)
Despite his missing ulnar collateral ligament and lost hype, Dickey advanced through the Rangers’ system, eventually making his debut with the big-league club in 2001. Only one problem: he wasn’t very good as a traditional pitcher.
Dickey bounced back and forth between the majors and minors over the next few seasons, sporting MLB season ERAs of 6.75, 5.09, 5.61 and 6.67.

The sporadic big league stops netted Dickey appearances in a few card releases, including 2004 Fleer Tradition and Topps Total, as well as 2005 Topps and Topps Heritage. But fastballs and curves weren’t enough to keep Dickey in the big leagues, and hopeful to prolong his career, Dickey developed a “forkball” in the minors.
Dickey made the Rangers out of spring training in 2006, and tried out his forkball in his first start of the season against the Tigers.
Six homeruns later, Dickey had tied a big league record for most HRs allowed in one game – and was back in the minors, back to cardboard obscurity.
Dickey bounced between the Texas, Milwaukee and Seattle systems in the following seasons, honing his “forkball,” which really turned out to be a fast knuckleball.
He also matured – finding closure in personal demons and re-establishing his spirituality, aspects of his life addressed in his memoir, “Wherever I Wind Up.” Dickey stopped worrying so much about every at-bat, and found comfort on the mound.
And he kept throwing his knuckleball.
The Mets signed the journeyman in 2010, and he opened the year with a 4-2 record and 2.23 ERA at AAA Buffalo, earning a return ticket to the majors.
Dickey and his knuckler won 11 games that season, and the Mets rewarded him with a two-year contract. Topps took notice, putting Dickey in four 2011 releases – Topps, Gypsy Queen, Heritage and Platinum, breaking Dickey’s six-year MLB card drought.
He also appears in 2012 Bowman, 15 years – 15 years! – following his first and only other Bowman release. Where the 1997 rookie card shows a posed, clean-shaven dreamer in a pristine white jersey, the 2012 card features Dickey in Mets black with a shaggy beard, his leg kicked high, ready to pitch, ready for battle.
Among current players, Dickey’s cardboard career most closely resembles that of Colby Lewis, another late-1990s and early-2000s Rangers prospect who bounced around – and spent six seasons without any MLB card issues – before finding late-career major league success.
But Dickey’s in a league of his own right now, baffling batters and astounding fans with his 11-1 record and 2.00 ERA. Just don’t expect to find many of his cards in your collection – not yet, anyway.